Choosing baseball cards often comes down to a specific tension: do you want a custom keepsake for a favorite team, a Bowman prospect card, or a Topps insert tied to a particular season? These four choices cover those lanes, but they differ in licensing, format, condition, and listed price. The clearest way to choose is to match the card's wording and attributes to the kind of collection you are building.
Quick take
- Custom Cardinals card: Josiah Ragsdale's fan-made card is the fit for a St. Louis Cardinals team-and-player keepsake.
- Custom Orioles card: Eric Booth Jr.'s card follows the same fan-made format for Baltimore Orioles collectors.
- Bowman prospect card: Joshua Baez's title includes Bowman 1st Prospect and Rookie RC language, with card number BP-112.
- Topps insert: The 2026 Topps card is the choice for a Topps insert connected to the 2026 season.
The listed-price span is $5, running from USD 3.00 to USD 8.00. The lower-priced choices are both custom cards, while the higher-priced choices use Bowman and Topps set language.
Listed-price comparison
| Card | Listed price | Price bar | Price position |
|---|---|---|---|
| Josiah Ragsdale Custom Baseball Card St. Louis Cardinals Fan Made | USD 3.00 | Lowest listed price, tied | |
| Eric Booth Jr. Custom Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles Fan Made | USD 3.00 | Lowest listed price, tied | |
| Joshua Baez 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect St Louis Cardinals Rookie RC HOT #BP-112 | USD 4.99 | Between the lowest and highest | |
| 2026 Topps Baseball Inserts Series 1 & 2-(A) Buy 3 Cards 50% Off 2-Card Minimum | USD 8.00 | Highest listed price |
Decision matrix
| If you want... | Start with... | Why it fits |
|---|---|---|
| A custom Cardinals keepsake | Josiah Ragsdale Custom Baseball Card St. Louis Cardinals Fan Made | The title names both Josiah Ragsdale and the St. Louis Cardinals, and the card is described as fan-made. |
| A custom Orioles keepsake | Eric Booth Jr. Custom Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles Fan Made | The title centers Eric Booth Jr. and the Baltimore Orioles in the same custom format. |
| Bowman prospect and rookie wording | Joshua Baez 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect St Louis Cardinals Rookie RC HOT #BP-112 | The title and attributes include Bowman, 1st Prospect, Rookie, Prospect, and BP-112. |
| A Topps insert from a named season | 2026 Topps Baseball Inserts Series 1 & 2-(A) Buy 3 Cards 50% Off 2-Card Minimum | Topps, 2026, and Insert are explicit parts of the card's identity. |
Product notes
Josiah Ragsdale Custom Baseball Card St. Louis Cardinals Fan Made
Josiah Ragsdale Custom Baseball Card St. Louis Cardinals Fan Made suits a collector who wants a player-and-team-specific keepsake in a custom format. Its description identifies a full-color, English-language MLB trading card for Josiah Ragsdale and the St. Louis Cardinals, with card number SS26-42. Those details make the team connection the clearest reason to choose it. The limitation is important: the card is fan-made and not officially licensed by Topps, Bowman, Panini, Upper Deck, or another major card company. It is also ungraded. At USD 3.00, it ties for the lowest listed price, but its purchase case is the custom design rather than a Topps or Bowman set release.
Eric Booth Jr. Custom Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles Fan Made
Eric Booth Jr. Custom Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles Fan Made gives an Orioles-focused collector a custom, fan-made direction with a different player and team from the Cardinals card. The description calls out a full-color English MLB trading card for Eric Booth Jr. and Baltimore, while card number SS26-69 supplies a specific identifying detail. That team-and-player pairing is the reason to select it for an Orioles-focused collection. The trade-off is that it is not officially licensed by Topps, Bowman, Panini, Upper Deck, or another major card company. It is ungraded and not autographed, so it does not fit a search specifically for graded or signed cards.
Joshua Baez 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect St Louis Cardinals Rookie RC HOT #BP-112
Joshua Baez 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect St Louis Cardinals Rookie RC HOT #BP-112 is a direct match for a shopper searching the title language Bowman, 1st Prospect, or Rookie RC. The attributes add card number BP-112, Base, standard size, 20 Pt. thickness, and features including Rookie and Prospect. Those identifiers give the card a defined Bowman prospect focus. The limitation is that it is ungraded and marked Autographed: No, so it is not the match for someone specifically seeking a graded or signed card. At USD 4.99, it sits between the two USD 3.00 custom cards and the USD 8.00 Topps entry.
2026 Topps Baseball Inserts Series 1 & 2-(A) Buy 3 Cards 50% Off 2-Card Minimum
2026 Topps Baseball Inserts Series 1 & 2-(A) Buy 3 Cards 50% Off 2-Card Minimum is aimed at a collector who wants a Topps insert tied to the 2026 season. Manufacturer Topps, Features: Insert, and the SMLB-59 Trey Yesavage RC - Toronto Blue Jays detail identify the format and featured card information. The purchase wording is a limitation for a single-card shopper: it includes a two-card minimum, alongside the buy-three/50%-off phrase. It is also ungraded and priced at USD 8.00, the highest listed price in this comparison. Choose it when the Topps insert format matters more than a lower entry price.
Final recommendation by use case
- For a custom St. Louis Cardinals keepsake: Choose the Josiah Ragsdale card, because its title and description pair the player with the Cardinals and identify a fan-made format.
- For a custom Baltimore Orioles keepsake: Choose the Eric Booth Jr. card, which names both the player and Orioles while carrying card number SS26-69.
- For Bowman prospect or rookie-card wording: Choose Joshua Baez's BP-112 card, whose title and attributes explicitly include Bowman 1st Prospect, Rookie, and Prospect.
- For a Topps insert tied to 2026: Choose the Topps card, where the manufacturer, season, and Insert feature are all specified. Its two-card minimum matters if you are not shopping for a single-card purchase.
The right pick is therefore less about one universal winner and more about format: custom fan-made cards for team-specific character, Bowman for prospect terminology, or Topps for a named insert and season.
