Choosing baseball cards means deciding what kind of collection addition you actually want: a personal team-focused card, a prospect or rookie issue, or a group of cards from an earlier season. The fastest way to narrow the field is to match the format to your collecting goal rather than treating every card as interchangeable.
Quick take
- For a Cardinals custom card: Josiah Ragsdale offers a full-color, fan-made format centered on the St. Louis Cardinals.
- For an Orioles custom card: Eric Booth Jr. provides the comparable Baltimore-focused choice, with its own card number and player focus.
- For a prospect or rookie card: Joshua Baez is the clearest match, with 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect wording plus Rookie and Prospect attributes.
- For set building: 1972 Topps Baseball Complete your Set #1-200 is the only choice framed as a numbered base set rather than a single-player card.
The custom cards are the most personal team-specific choices. The Joshua Baez card is aimed at a named prospect and rookie theme, while the 1972 Topps entry is the broadest set-oriented pick.
Listed-price comparison
| Card | Listed price | Price bar |
|---|---|---|
| Josiah Ragsdale Custom Baseball Card St. Louis Cardinals Fan Made | USD 3.00 | |
| Eric Booth Jr. Custom Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles Fan Made | USD 3.00 | |
| Joshua Baez 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect St Louis Cardinals Rookie RC HOT #BP-112 | USD 4.99 | |
| 1972 Topps Baseball Complete your Set #1-200 | USD 5.25 |
Decision matrix
- Personalized team connection: Choose between the Josiah Ragsdale Cardinals card and the Eric Booth Jr. Orioles card based on the player and team you want represented. Both are explicitly custom, fan-made cards.
- Prospect or rookie focus: Joshua Baez is the direct match because the title identifies a 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect card and the attributes include Rookie and Prospect.
- A numbered set project: The 1972 Topps card group is the natural fit for someone focused on cards #1-200 and a Base Set format.
- Price as the first filter: The absolute spread from the lowest to highest listed price is $2.25. That separates the two custom cards from the Joshua Baez and 1972 Topps entries without implying that one collecting format is inherently better.
- Condition expectations: All four cards are listed as ungraded. The 1972 Topps description adds that conditions vary, with most cards described as Excellent, some VG, and some NrMT+.
Product notes
Josiah Ragsdale Custom Baseball Card St. Louis Cardinals Fan Made
Josiah Ragsdale is the clearest fit for a St. Louis Cardinals fan who wants a player-specific custom card rather than a conventional set entry. The full-color design and custom trading-card format give it a personal, fan-made character, while card number SS26-42 distinguishes it within the custom set. The main limitation is also the defining feature: it is explicitly fan-made and not an officially licensed product from a major trading-card company. It is also not autographed. Choose it when the player-and-team connection matters more than owning a traditional Bowman, Topps, or other established set card.
Eric Booth Jr. Custom Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles Fan Made
Eric Booth Jr. brings the same custom-card concept to Baltimore Orioles fans. Its player and team pairing makes the choice straightforward for a collector building around the Orioles, and card number SS26-69 gives the card a specific place in the custom set. The full-color fan-made presentation is a concrete reason to select it for a team-focused collection or a personal display. Its limitation is that it is not an officially licensed major-company card, and the attributes identify it as not autographed. Pick this card when Eric Booth Jr. and Baltimore are the priority, not when the goal is a conventional prospect or vintage set format.
Joshua Baez 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect St Louis Cardinals Rookie RC HOT #BP-112
Joshua Baez shifts the comparison toward a named prospect and rookie card. The title identifies a 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect card, while the attributes specify Base, Standard size, 20 Pt. thickness, Rookie, Prospect, and card number BP-112. That combination gives shoppers several concrete identifiers for a single-card collection organized around Bowman prospect issues. The limitation is that the card is not autographed, and its condition is ungraded. Select it when the Bowman 1st Prospect and rookie framing are more important than a fan-made design or a multi-card set. The listed St. Louis connection also keeps it relevant to Cardinals-focused collecting.
1972 Topps Baseball Complete your Set #1-200
The 1972 Topps entry is the most set-oriented choice in the group. Its title specifies Complete your Set #1-200, and the attributes identify Topps, a Base Set, English language, Major League Baseball, and the 1972 season. That makes it the practical match for someone who wants a wider run of baseball cards rather than a single custom or prospect card. The limitation is condition variation: the description says most cards are Excellent, while some are VG and some are NrMT+. It is also a different collecting experience from the player-specific cards, so choose it for the 1972 Topps set goal rather than a single-player focus.
Final recommendation by use case
- Choose Josiah Ragsdale for a Cardinals-centered custom card with a fan-made presentation.
- Choose Eric Booth Jr. for the equivalent Orioles-focused collecting path.
- Choose Joshua Baez when the exact target is a 2022 Bowman 1st Prospect card with Rookie and Prospect designations.
- Choose 1972 Topps Baseball Complete your Set #1-200 for a base-set project tied to the 1972 season.
The decision comes down to format: custom team card, Bowman prospect card, or numbered Topps set. The price table then shows how much each direction differs before you make the final selection.
