Choosing sports memorabilia cards is often a choice between the athlete you want, the memorabilia format you prefer, and how far you want to go on serial numbering. These four Arts & Graphs cards split neatly between baseball and basketball, while the Magic Johnson option adds a patch and the other three use jersey memorabilia. This guide separates the choices so you can focus on the card that fits your collection.
Quick take
Start with sport. The Vladimir Guerrero and Don Mattingly cards are the baseball selections, while Toby Fournier and Magic Johnson cover basketball. For memorabilia format, Vladimir Guerrero, Toby Fournier, and Don Mattingly are jersey autograph cards; Magic Johnson is the listed patch autograph choice. Serial numbers range from #6/20 to #2/3, giving each card a distinct numbered identity.
All four are original, English-language, ungraded sports trading cards with Leaf autograph authentication and label or sticker autograph formats. The lower listed-price pair is Vladimir Guerrero and Toby Fournier, so sport and the #6/20 versus #5/5 serial are the main ways to separate those two.
Listed-price comparison
| Card | Listed price | Relative listed price |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 Art of Sport Arts & Graphs Vladimir Guerrero Jersey Autograph #6/20 SEALED | USD 25.78 | |
| 2026 Art of Sport Arts & Graphs Green Toby Fournier Jersey Autograph #5/5 SEALED | USD 25.78 | |
| 2026 Art of Sport Arts Graphs Purple Don Mattingly Jersey Autograph #2/8 SEALED | USD 125.78 | |
| 2026 Art of Sport Arts & Graphs Red Magic Johnson Patch Autograph #2/3 SEALED | USD 149.78 |
Decision matrix
- For a Vladimir Guerrero baseball card: choose the jersey autograph numbered #6/20.
- For a Don Mattingly baseball card with Purple Holofoil wording: choose the jersey autograph numbered #2/8.
- For a Toby Fournier basketball card: choose the Green jersey autograph numbered #5/5.
- For a Magic Johnson basketball card with patch memorabilia: choose the Red patch autograph numbered #2/3.
- For a shared format: each selection is autographed, serial numbered, ungraded, and includes memorabilia.
Product notes
Vladimir Guerrero Jersey Autograph #6/20
The 2026 Art of Sport Arts & Graphs Vladimir Guerrero Jersey Autograph #6/20 SEALED is the straightforward pick for a baseball-focused collection centered on Guerrero. Its jersey memorabilia, autograph, and #6/20 serial number create a clear theme without moving into the higher listed-price tier occupied by the Mattingly and Magic Johnson cards. It is also identified as an insert, alongside memorabilia and serial-numbered features. The limitation is format rather than athlete: this is an ungraded card with a label or sticker autograph, so it is best for shoppers specifically comfortable with that presentation.
Green Toby Fournier Jersey Autograph #5/5
Choose the 2026 Art of Sport Arts & Graphs Green Toby Fournier Jersey Autograph #5/5 SEALED when basketball is the priority and a Green parallel/variety card is the right fit. The #5/5 serial distinguishes it from the other lower listed-price option, while the jersey memorabilia and autograph keep the focus on a familiar memorabilia-card combination. It is especially easy to narrow down for a Toby Fournier collector because it is the only listed Fournier card. Its trade-off is that it remains ungraded and uses a label or sticker autograph rather than offering a different autograph format.
Purple Don Mattingly Jersey Autograph #2/8
The 2026 Art of Sport Arts Graphs Purple Don Mattingly Jersey Autograph #2/8 SEALED suits collectors seeking a baseball card tied to Don Mattingly and a Purple Holofoil parallel/variety presentation. Its #2/8 serial number is lower than the Vladimir Guerrero card's #6/20, and the card combines an autograph with jersey memorabilia. At USD 125.78, it sits well above the two USD 25.78 cards, making the athlete and Purple treatment the reasons to choose it rather than simply the shared autograph-and-memorabilia setup. The limitation is that it is still ungraded with a label or sticker autograph format.
Red Magic Johnson Patch Autograph #2/3
The 2026 Art of Sport Arts & Graphs Red Magic Johnson Patch Autograph #2/3 SEALED is the choice for a Magic Johnson-focused basketball collection where patch memorabilia matters. It is the only patch autograph in this group, and its Red Holofoil description plus #2/3 serial number make it the most distinct format-and-number combination among the four. The listed price is the highest in the comparison, so it makes the most sense when the Johnson name, patch element, and #2/3 numbering are the priorities. As with every card here, the limitation is that it is ungraded and carries a label or sticker autograph.
Final recommendation by use case
Pick Vladimir Guerrero #6/20 for a baseball jersey autograph at the lower listed-price point. Choose Toby Fournier Green #5/5 for basketball jersey memorabilia and a Green parallel/variety. Go with Don Mattingly Purple #2/8 when the player and Purple Holofoil presentation are central to the purchase. Select Magic Johnson Red Patch #2/3 when a patch autograph and the lowest serial denominator in this group are your deciding factors.
