Choosing sports memorabilia often comes down to what kind of collecting story you want: a serial-numbered UFC relic, a low-cost fighter memorabilia card, an autographed college football piece, or a baseball jersey card tied to a specific player and print run. The four choices here sit far apart in listed price, with a range from USD 4.00 to USD 200.00, so the best pick depends less on a single "winner" and more on whether you prioritize athlete, sport, autograph status, memorabilia features, or scarcity wording.
Quick take
- Best for a scarce UFC relic focus: 2026 UFC Topps Knockout Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos Quad Relic Card /5 (3/5, because the title and attributes center on a Quad Relic Card, serial numbering, and a print run of 5.
- Best for the lowest listed price: 2011 Topps UFC Title Shot - Fighter Relics Chris Leben #FR-CL (MEM, because it is the clear low end of the group and still includes memorabilia wording.
- Best for an autograph-centered football pick: OHIO STATE NATIONAL CHAMPIONS TREVEYON HENDERSON AUTO COLLECTORSXT ART COA SWAU, because it is listed as autographed and hard signed.
- Best for a baseball jersey-card angle: 2004 SKYBOX JERSEY GRAPHICS ALEX RODRIGUEZ GAME USED JERSEY BLUE 34/250, because the title points to Alex Rodriguez, a game-used jersey piece, and numbering to 250.
Listed price comparison
| Product | Listed price | Relative bar |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 UFC Topps Knockout Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos Quad Relic Card /5 (3/5 | USD 200.00 | |
| 2011 Topps UFC Title Shot - Fighter Relics Chris Leben #FR-CL (MEM | USD 4.00 | |
| OHIO STATE NATIONAL CHAMPIONS TREVEYON HENDERSON AUTO COLLECTORSXT ART COA SWAU | USD 38.15 | |
| 2004 SKYBOX JERSEY GRAPHICS ALEX RODRIGUEZ GAME USED JERSEY BLUE 34/250 | USD 19.99 |
The price spread is large: the lowest listed option is 98% below the highest listed option. That makes the Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos card a very different decision from the Chris Leben card, even though both sit in the UFC memorabilia lane. The Alex Rodriguez and Treveyon Henderson choices fall between those extremes and appeal to different sports and collector preferences.
Decision matrix
| If you care most about... | Lean toward | Why it fits |
|---|---|---|
| UFC scarcity language | 2026 UFC Topps Knockout Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos Quad Relic Card /5 (3/5 | The title includes Quad Relic Card and /5, while the attributes include Memorabilia and Serial Numbered. |
| Keeping the spend minimal | 2011 Topps UFC Title Shot - Fighter Relics Chris Leben #FR-CL (MEM | It is the lowest listed choice and still has Fighter Relics and memorabilia language. |
| A signed football collectible | OHIO STATE NATIONAL CHAMPIONS TREVEYON HENDERSON AUTO COLLECTORSXT ART COA SWAU | It is marked Autographed: Yes and Autograph Format: Hard Signed. |
| Baseball memorabilia with numbering | 2004 SKYBOX JERSEY GRAPHICS ALEX RODRIGUEZ GAME USED JERSEY BLUE 34/250 | The title includes game-used jersey wording and 34/250. |
| Ungraded cards | Any of the four | Each choice is listed as ungraded. |
| Avoiding autographs | Chris Leben or Alex Rodriguez | Both are listed as not autographed. |
Concise product notes
2026 UFC Topps Knockout Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos Quad Relic Card /5 (3/5
This is the most focused choice for a collector who wants a UFC card with scarcity language built into the title. The Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos card is described as a Quad Relic Card, part of a UFC Relics Card insert set, and it carries memorabilia plus serial-numbered features. The /5 and (3/5) wording makes it the standout for someone who wants a card defined by a very small print-run phrase. The limitation is straightforward: it is the highest listed price in this group by a wide margin, so it makes the most sense for a collector who specifically wants this UFC athlete and relic format rather than just an entry-level memorabilia card.
2011 Topps UFC Title Shot - Fighter Relics Chris Leben #FR-CL (MEM
The Chris Leben Fighter Relics card is the easiest pick to justify when the goal is adding a UFC memorabilia card at the low end of the comparison. It is a 2011 Topps UFC Title Shot card with card number FR-CL, standard card size, and a 35 Pt. thickness listed. It is also marked as not autographed, which may suit collectors who want the relic aspect without paying for autograph appeal. Its limitation is that it does not have the serial-numbered /5 language of the Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos card, so the collecting draw is more about Chris Leben, Topps UFC Title Shot, and Fighter Relics than extreme scarcity wording.
OHIO STATE NATIONAL CHAMPIONS TREVEYON HENDERSON AUTO COLLECTORSXT ART COA SWAU
The Treveyon Henderson card is the clearest match for a shopper who wants an autographed sports memorabilia piece tied to Ohio State and NCAA football. It is listed as autographed, with a hard-signed autograph format, and the title emphasizes Ohio State National Champions, Treveyon Henderson, Auto, CollectorsXT Art, COA, and SWAU. That combination gives it a different collecting purpose than the relic-only UFC and baseball cards. The tradeoff is that it is not a UFC or MLB memorabilia card, and it is listed as ungraded, so it fits best when the player, Ohio State theme, and autograph format matter more than league consistency with the other card options.
2004 SKYBOX JERSEY GRAPHICS ALEX RODRIGUEZ GAME USED JERSEY BLUE 34/250
The Alex Rodriguez SkyBox card is the strongest baseball-oriented pick in the set. The title centers on a 2004 SkyBox Jersey Graphics card, game-used jersey wording, Blue, and 34/250 numbering. It is also listed with insert, memorabilia, and short print features, while the autograph line says no. That makes it appealing for someone who wants a player-specific baseball jersey card rather than a signed card. The limitation is that the appeal is concentrated around Alex Rodriguez and the Jerseygraphics insert angle; shoppers looking for UFC relics or a hard-signed football card will find the Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos, Chris Leben, or Treveyon Henderson choices more aligned.
How to choose among them
Start with the sport, then move to the memorabilia format. If UFC is the priority, the choice narrows quickly to Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos versus Chris Leben. The Santos card is the more scarcity-driven option, with Quad Relic Card and /5 wording, while the Leben card is the lower-cost route into a Topps UFC Title Shot Fighter Relics card. A UFC collector who wants a headline scarcity phrase will likely gravitate toward Santos; a collector who wants a Chris Leben relic card without the same spend will likely prefer the 2011 Title Shot option.
If autograph status matters, Treveyon Henderson is the outlier in a useful way. It is the only card here marked as autographed, and the hard-signed format separates it from the three memorabilia-card choices that either are not autographed or do not present the autograph as the main feature. The Ohio State National Champions wording also gives it a team-and-season identity that the other products do not share.
If baseball is the target, the Alex Rodriguez card is the natural fit. Its appeal rests on the player name, SkyBox Jersey Graphics set language, and game-used jersey wording. It is also numbered 34/250 in the title, giving it a defined print-run phrase without reaching the tiny /5 level of the Santos UFC card.
Final recommendation
Pick 2026 UFC Topps Knockout Mauricio "Ruffy" Santos Quad Relic Card /5 (3/5 if you want the most scarcity-focused UFC choice and are comfortable with the USD 200.00 listed price. Choose 2011 Topps UFC Title Shot - Fighter Relics Chris Leben #FR-CL (MEM if the USD 4.00 listing is the deciding factor and a UFC Fighter Relics card is enough. Go with OHIO STATE NATIONAL CHAMPIONS TREVEYON HENDERSON AUTO COLLECTORSXT ART COA SWAU if a hard-signed NCAA football card is the priority. Choose 2004 SKYBOX JERSEY GRAPHICS ALEX RODRIGUEZ GAME USED JERSEY BLUE 34/250 if you want the baseball path, especially the Alex Rodriguez game-used jersey and 34/250 title details.