A sports memorabilia card can take very different forms: an accessible fight-mat relic, a signed UFC card, a football pairing with memorabilia, or a graded one-of-one crossover piece. The useful choice is not simply which card costs more; it is which collecting focus you want represented. Start by narrowing the field to UFC, Pittsburgh Steelers football, or a multi-athlete Quad Memorabilia card, then decide how much serial numbering, an autograph, or grading matters to you.
Quick take
The 2010 Topps UFC Chuck Liddell Fight Mat Relic #FM-CL is the lowest-listed-price route into this group and centers on a non-autographed UFC fight-mat relic. The 2024 Topps Knockout Dricus Du Plessis Autograph Jumbo Fight Mat Relic /199 adds a hard-signed autograph and jumbo fight-mat format. For Steelers collectors, the 2026 Leaf Art of Sport Terry Bradshaw Stallworth Steelers Game Used Relic #12/25 focuses on the Bradshaw and Stallworth pairing in the Battle Worn insert set. The 2023 Presidents Choice QUAD GOAT PSA 10 1/1 Plante/Reggie/Namath/Tyson Relic is the outlier: a graded 1/1 that brings four named athletes together.
Listed-price comparison
The listed prices span $12.99 to $449.99, so the choice ranges from a single-athlete relic card to a graded one-of-one Quad Memorabilia card.
| Card | Listed price | Relative listed-price position |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 Presidents Choice QUAD GOAT PSA 10 1/1 Plante/Reggie/Namath/Tyson Relic | USD 449.99 | |
| 2026 Leaf Art of Sport Terry Bradshaw Stallworth Steelers Game Used Relic #12/25 | USD 74.99 | |
| 2010 Topps UFC Chuck Liddell Fight Mat Relic #FM-CL | USD 12.99 | |
| 2024 Topps Knockout Dricus Du Plessis Autograph Jumbo Fight Mat Relic /199 | USD 39.99 |
Decision matrix
- For a graded serial-numbered centerpiece: choose the Presidents Choice QUAD GOAT card, identified as PSA 10 and 1/1.
- For a Steelers-oriented memorabilia card: choose the Leaf Art of Sport Battle Worn card featuring Terry Bradshaw and John Stallworth.
- For a Chuck Liddell UFC memorabilia card without an autograph: choose the 2010 Topps Fight Mat Relic.
- For a Dricus Du Plessis card that combines an autograph with memorabilia: choose the 2024 Topps Knockout AJFM-DD.
Product notes
2023 Presidents Choice QUAD GOAT PSA 10 1/1 Plante/Reggie/Namath/Tyson Relic
Pick this card when the goal is a single display piece built around multiple sports names rather than one athlete or team. Its Quad Memorabilia format names Plante, Reggie Jackson, Joe Namath, and Mike Tyson, while the PSA 10 grade and 1/1 card number make its collecting identity especially specific. It is also an original Presidents Choice release with memorabilia and serial-numbered features. The tradeoff is straightforward: at USD 449.99, it carries the highest listed price in this comparison. That makes the most sense for a collector who specifically wants the graded one-of-one format and this unusual four-name combination.
2026 Leaf Art of Sport Terry Bradshaw Stallworth Steelers Game Used Relic #12/25
This is the focused football choice for someone who wants Terry Bradshaw and John Stallworth on the same Steelers-themed memorabilia card. The card belongs to Leaf's Battle Worn insert set, carries card number BW-37, and is numbered 12/25. Those details give it a clearer team-and-era collecting lane than the UFC selections. Its USD 74.99 listed price places it between the low-cost Chuck Liddell relic and the graded Quad GOAT card. One limitation is its ungraded condition, so it is best suited to collectors prioritizing the named pairing, Battle Worn insert designation, and memorabilia theme over a graded presentation.
2010 Topps UFC Chuck Liddell Fight Mat Relic #FM-CL
Choose the Chuck Liddell card for a direct, earlier-era UFC relic centered on one fighter. It is a 2010 Topps original from the Fight Mat Relics insert set, with card number FM-CL and a piece of fight memorabilia. At USD 12.99, it has the lowest listed price of the four cards, making it the clearest pick when you want a Chuck Liddell collectible without moving into the higher-priced crossover or autograph options. The limitation is explicit: it is not autographed. It is also ungraded, so its appeal rests on the Liddell subject, Topps issue, and Fight Mat Relics designation.
2024 Topps Knockout Dricus Du Plessis Autograph Jumbo Fight Mat Relic /199
The Dricus Du Plessis card is the choice for a UFC collector who wants both a hard-signed autograph and a jumbo fight-mat relic on one card. It is numbered /199, carries card number AJFM-DD, and lists Topps for autograph authentication. Its USD 39.99 listed price keeps it much closer to the Chuck Liddell card than to the Quad GOAT 1/1 while adding an autograph format absent from the Liddell selection. The constraint is that it is ungraded. Choose it for the specific autograph-and-memorabilia combination, not for a graded-card presentation.
Final recommendation by use case
For the lowest listed-price UFC memorabilia choice, select the 2010 Topps UFC Chuck Liddell Fight Mat Relic #FM-CL. Choose the 2024 Topps Knockout Dricus Du Plessis Autograph Jumbo Fight Mat Relic /199 when a hard-signed autograph is central to the decision. Steelers collectors should prioritize the 2026 Leaf Art of Sport Terry Bradshaw Stallworth Steelers Game Used Relic #12/25. Reserve the 2023 Presidents Choice QUAD GOAT PSA 10 1/1 Plante/Reggie/Namath/Tyson Relic for a collection seeking a graded 1/1 with a four-athlete memorabilia concept.
