Choosing sports memorabilia often comes down to the kind of collecting goal you have: an authenticated autograph, a graded card, a relic card, a limited serial-numbered piece, or a specific athlete or sport. The four cards here span football, UFC, baseball, and broader art-of-sport memorabilia, with listed prices ranging from USD 14.99 to USD 274.99. That makes the decision less about finding one universal winner and more about matching the card's format, athlete, grading status, and memorabilia features to your collection.
Quick take
- Best fit for a graded football autograph: 2016 HISTORIC AUTOGRAPHS ART OF FOOTBALL RAYMOND BERRY /46 PSA 10 AUTO GRADE, because it combines Raymond Berry, a hard-signed autograph, PSA authentication, and an oversized card format.
- Best fit for a graded UFC autograph: 2026 Topps UFC Quillan Salkilld Midnight auto Dusk /75 Graded BGS 9 MINT, with a hard-signed Quillan Salkilld autograph and BGS 9 MINT grading.
- Best fit for the lowest listed entry point: 2016 Topps Museum Collection - Single Fighter Signature Swatches Dual Relic /99, which centers on a Topps-authenticated sticker autograph format and dual relic theme.
- Best fit for an Ichiro relic collector: 2021 Leaf Art of Sport - Paint by Numbers Relics Ichiro Suzuki Bronze /30 (MEM, because it is a non-autographed memorabilia card tied to Ichiro Suzuki and a bronze /30 format.
Listed price comparison
The spread is wide: the lowest listed price is USD 14.99 and the highest listed price is USD 274.99, meaning the lowest sits about 95% below the highest. That gap matters because the cards are not all trying to do the same job. Two are graded autographs, one is an ungraded autograph-relic style card, and one is an ungraded non-autographed relic card.
| Card | Listed price | Relative price |
|---|---|---|
| 2016 Topps Museum Collection - Single Fighter Signature Swatches Dual Relic /99 | USD 14.99 | |
| 2016 HISTORIC AUTOGRAPHS ART OF FOOTBALL RAYMOND BERRY /46 PSA 10 AUTO GRADE | USD 41.98 | |
| 2021 Leaf Art of Sport - Paint by Numbers Relics Ichiro Suzuki Bronze /30 (MEM | USD 110.00 | |
| 2026 Topps UFC Quillan Salkilld Midnight auto Dusk /75 Graded BGS 9 MINT | USD 274.99 |
Decision matrix
Choose the Raymond Berry card if you want football history plus a graded autograph. It is the only National Football League card in this group, and its PSA authentication, PSA 10 auto grade language, hard-signed format, oversized card size, and serial-numbered limited-edition features give it a clear collector profile.
Choose the Quillan Salkilld card if your priority is a modern UFC graded autograph. It has Topps autograph authentication, a hard-signed format, BGS 9 MINT grading, and Dusk /75 wording in the title. It is also the highest listed card in this comparison, so it makes the most sense for a shopper specifically seeking that UFC subject and graded-auto combination.
Choose the Topps Museum Collection card if you want the lowest listed price and an autograph-relic theme. It is ungraded, uses a label or sticker autograph format, and includes memorabilia and serial-numbered features. That makes it a more accessible way to add a signature swatches dual relic style card without moving into the higher listed prices here.
Choose the Ichiro Suzuki Leaf card if the athlete and relic format matter more than an autograph. It is explicitly marked Autographed: No, but it includes memorabilia, serial-numbered, short print, and bronze /30 language. For an Ichiro-focused collection, that combination may be more relevant than chasing a signed card from another sport.
Concise product notes
2016 HISTORIC AUTOGRAPHS ART OF FOOTBALL RAYMOND BERRY /46 PSA 10 AUTO GRADE
This Raymond Berry card stands out for shoppers who want a football autograph with grading language attached. The title calls out PSA 10 AUTO GRADE, while the attributes include Professional Sports Authenticator authentication, a hard-signed autograph, oversized card size, and National Football League association. The limited /46 wording and features such as serial numbered, short print, memorabilia, and limited edition also give it several collector-friendly hooks. The tradeoff is that it is very specific: if your collection is focused on standard-size cards, UFC, baseball, or non-autographed relics, this oversized football autograph will not be the most natural match.
2026 Topps UFC Quillan Salkilld Midnight auto Dusk /75 Graded BGS 9 MINT
The Quillan Salkilld card is the clearest choice for someone looking for a graded UFC autograph among these four. It pairs Topps autograph authentication with a hard-signed format, a standard card size, BGS 9 MINT grading, and a Dusk /75 identifier in the title. The attributes also list parallel/variety, memorabilia, serial numbered, and short print features, which gives it more than just the autograph angle. Its limitation is the commitment required by its USD 274.99 listed price; it is the top end of this set, so it is best suited to a shopper who specifically wants this fighter, UFC theme, and graded-card profile.
2016 Topps Museum Collection - Single Fighter Signature Swatches Dual Relic /99
This Topps Museum Collection card is the easiest entry point by listed price, at USD 14.99, while still carrying autograph and relic-style appeal. It has Topps autograph authentication, a label or sticker autograph format, a standard card size, Near Mint or Better card condition language, and an insert set tied to Single Fighter Signature Swatches Dual Relic Autographs. Features include insert, memorabilia, and serial numbered, so it can work for a shopper who wants a signature swatches concept without paying graded-card money. The limitation is that it is ungraded and the autograph is not hard signed, which may matter to collectors who prioritize slabbed cards or on-card signatures.
2021 Leaf Art of Sport - Paint by Numbers Relics Ichiro Suzuki Bronze /30 (MEM
The Ichiro Suzuki Leaf Art of Sport card is the strongest fit here for a baseball collector who wants a relic rather than an autograph. Its title names Ichiro Suzuki and Bronze /30, and the attributes include memorabilia, parallel/variety, serial numbered, short print, English language, and MLB World Series event wording. Because it is ungraded and marked Autographed: No, it should be viewed as a memorabilia-focused Ichiro piece, not a signed-card purchase. That is also its main limitation: collectors comparing only autographed cards may prefer one of the other options, while Ichiro-focused shoppers may appreciate the relic emphasis.
Final recommendation
For most shoppers, the right pick depends on which collecting lane matters most. If you want the most affordable way into this group, the 2016 Topps Museum Collection - Single Fighter Signature Swatches Dual Relic /99 is the straightforward choice because it has the lowest listed price at USD 14.99 and still includes autograph, memorabilia, and serial-numbered elements.
If your goal is a graded football autograph, the 2016 HISTORIC AUTOGRAPHS ART OF FOOTBALL RAYMOND BERRY /46 PSA 10 AUTO GRADE offers the strongest mix of NFL subject matter, hard-signed format, PSA authentication, and oversized presentation. If your priority is a modern UFC graded autograph, the 2026 Topps UFC Quillan Salkilld Midnight auto Dusk /75 Graded BGS 9 MINT is the most direct match, though it also defines the top of the price spread. For baseball memorabilia, the 2021 Leaf Art of Sport - Paint by Numbers Relics Ichiro Suzuki Bronze /30 (MEM is the more focused choice, especially if an Ichiro relic card is more appealing to you than an autograph from another sport.