Choosing Between a One-of-One Quad Card and a Graded Hockey Card
For sports memorabilia shoppers, the key question here is whether you want a multi-athlete card with a one-of-one designation or a graded, player-specific hockey card with a stated serial number. The 2026 Leaf Art of Sport Ruth, Williams, Mays, Clemente 1/1 Game-Used Holo Black centers on four names in the Classic Quads insert set. The Sergei Fedorov 2022 Leaf Art Of Hockey Enshrined Exhibit Materials Bronze 21/45 is focused on Fedorov and NHL memorabilia-card collecting.
Quick verdict
Pick the Ruth, Williams, Mays, and Clemente card when the appeal is a four-athlete composition, the Holo Black parallel, and a One of One feature. Its listed price is USD 499.99, and it is ungraded.
Choose the Sergei Fedorov card when a graded card and a clearly stated 21/45 serial number matter more than a quad-player format. At USD 200.00, it sits USD 299.99 below the other card while remaining a memorabilia insert with a Bronze parallel/variety designation.
At-a-glance comparison
| Detail | Ruth, Williams, Mays, Clemente 1/1 | Sergei Fedorov Bronze 21/45 |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | USD 499.99 | USD 200.00 |
| Focus | Four named athletes; Classic Quads | Sergei Fedorov; NHL |
| Numbering | One of One | 21/45 |
| Condition designation | Ungraded | Graded |
| Format details | 180 Pt.; Holo Black | Bronze; card stock |
| Shared card traits | Standard size; memorabilia insert; not autographed | Standard size; memorabilia insert; not autographed |
Where each card stands out
Ruth, Williams, Mays, Clemente 1/1: for the multi-athlete centerpiece
The Leaf Art of Sport card is the more focused choice for someone drawn to a single card featuring Ruth, Williams, Mays, and Clemente together. Its Classic Quads insert-set placement supports that multi-subject format, while the Holo Black wording and One of One feature make its identity especially specific. The 180 Pt. thickness is another listed physical detail for collectors who pay attention to card construction. This choice is less aligned with shoppers who specifically want a graded card, because its condition designation is ungraded.
Sergei Fedorov Bronze 21/45: for the hockey-specific collection
The Leaf Art Of Hockey Enshrined Exhibit Materials Bronze card suits a collection centered on Sergei Fedorov, the NHL, or Detroit Red Wings memorabilia. It is numbered 21 out of 45 and carries Limited Edition and Parallel/Variety features, giving the card a defined place within its 2022 Leaf Art Of Hockey context. Graded condition is the clearest distinction for a collector who prefers that designation. The trade-off is scope: this is a single-player hockey card rather than the four-athlete Classic Quads presentation of the Leaf Art of Sport card.
Product notes
2026 Leaf Art of Sport Ruth, Williams, Mays, Clemente 1/1 Game-Used Holo Black
Choose this card for the combination of Ruth, Williams, Mays, and Clemente on one standard-size Classic Quads card. The One of One feature is the central reason to favor it, and the title's Holo Black designation adds another specific parallel identity. Memorabilia, insert, serial-numbered, and parallel/variety features reinforce that it is built around a distinctive collectible-card format rather than an autograph. The card is also listed at 180 Pt., a detail that separates it from a typical thin-card expectation. Its main limitation is straightforward: the condition designation is ungraded, so it is not the pick for a shopper whose priority is a graded Fedorov-style card.
Sergei Fedorov 2022 Leaf Art Of Hockey Enshrined Exhibit Materials Bronze 21/45
This is the logical choice for a Sergei Fedorov or NHL collection, particularly one connected with his Detroit Red Wings career. The 21/45 numbering gives it a concrete limited-edition identifier, and the Bronze parallel/variety wording provides a clear collecting angle within 2022 Leaf Art Of Hockey. Graded condition is the strongest reason to select it over the ungraded quad card, while the memorabilia and insert features keep it within the same broad card category. The limitation is the narrower subject matter: Fedorov is the sole named athlete, so it does not offer the cross-sport, four-name presentation of Ruth, Williams, Mays, and Clemente.
Final choice by collecting goal
Select the Ruth, Williams, Mays, Clemente 1/1 for a one-of-one Classic Quads card with a multi-athlete focus. Select the Sergei Fedorov Bronze 21/45 for a graded NHL memorabilia card with a stated 21-of-45 serial number. The decision comes down to whether the priority is singular quad-card format or graded, player-specific hockey collecting.
