For tcg singles & decks shoppers, the key decision is whether you want the surprise of a pull or control over a defined card from a named edition. These two Magic: The Gathering options sit just $0.08 apart, but they serve different purposes: MTG: Magic the Gathering ~Single Pulls Go right to the Rares is framed around finding varied cards, while Magic: The Gathering, Revised Edition, Card Singles centers on Revised Edition singles you pick. The right choice depends less on the small price gap and more on how much control you want over the card.
Quick verdict
Choose MTG: Magic the Gathering ~Single Pulls Go right to the Rares if you want an exploratory purchase with many unique old and new cards, including references to 1st Edition and Base Set cards. Choose Magic: The Gathering, Revised Edition, Card Singles when selecting from a defined edition is the priority. The pull option is priced at $1.60, compared with $1.68 for the Revised Edition singles, a straightforward $0.08 spread. The practical divider is pull-style discovery versus a you-pick format.
Price and attribute snapshot
| Product | Listed price | Choice cue | Condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| MTG: Magic the Gathering ~Single Pulls Go right to the Rares | $1.60 | Single pulls with varied card possibilities | Ungraded |
| Magic: The Gathering, Revised Edition, Card Singles | $1.68 | Revised Edition singles; you pick | Ungraded |
Where each product wins
- Discovery and variety - MTG: Magic the Gathering ~Single Pulls Go right to the Rares: Its description highlights many unique old and new cards, making the pull format the more direct fit for shoppers who enjoy finding out what turns up.
- Selection and edition focus - Magic: The Gathering, Revised Edition, Card Singles: The description says you pick, and the product title puts Revised Edition at the center. That makes it the clearer choice when the edition matters more than surprise.
Product notes
MTG: Magic the Gathering ~Single Pulls Go right to the Rares
The appeal of MTG: Magic the Gathering ~Single Pulls Go right to the Rares is the open-ended hunt. Its description highlights many unique and fun old and new cards, while the feature list calls out 1st Edition and Base Set cards. That makes it a natural choice when the surprise of a pull matters more than naming a particular card first. English language and card-stock construction are also specified. The limitation is equally clear: the purchase is framed as single pulls and finding cards, not as a preselected Revised Edition card. It does not identify a particular card in advance, so shoppers seeking a defined edition or exact selection may prefer the other format. Choose this one for variety-oriented browsing and the title's rare-focused pull concept.
Magic: The Gathering, Revised Edition, Card Singles
Magic: The Gathering, Revised Edition, Card Singles takes a more defined route. The description says you pick, and the title centers Revised Edition, so it fits a shopper who wants selection rather than an open-ended pull. The card details also specify blue cards, standard size, regular finish, and English language, giving the purchase a clear profile without claiming those specifications are superior. The limitation is condition: the cards are ungraded, and the description says cards that are not near mint will be marked as such in the name. That makes condition wording part of the decision. Pick this option when a Revised Edition card you select is the use case; it is less suitable for shoppers specifically requiring a graded card.
Final choice by use case
- Choose MTG: Magic the Gathering ~Single Pulls Go right to the Rares for surprise: The title's pull format and its emphasis on many unique old and new cards fit an exploratory purchase.
- Choose Magic: The Gathering, Revised Edition, Card Singles for control: Its Revised Edition focus and you-pick wording are the concrete reasons to choose it when selection comes first.
- Choose based on price only when the formats are otherwise equal for you: The $0.08 spread favors the MTG single-pull option, but the format difference is more meaningful than the small gap for most use cases.
