Choosing among comics collectibles often comes down to what kind of collection you are building: graded key issue, character-focused cover, unread variant, or DC team-family display piece. The four picks here sit far apart in listed price, with the lowest at USD 4.74 and the highest at USD 124.00, so the better choice depends on whether you want the strongest slabbed Supergirl angle, the lowest entry point, or a modern variant with specific characters and cover appeal.
Quick take
- Best for a graded Supergirl-focused collectible: Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow #1 CGC 9.8 1st Print Bilquis Evely Cover Tom King, because the title and attributes center on Kara Zor-El, Supergirl, a first printing, a key issue, and CGC 9.8 presentation.
- Best lowest listed price: Catwoman #89 Cover E Homare Swimsuit Card Stock Variant, which is the least expensive pick in this group and carries DC Comics plus a Brand New condition note.
- Best for a surprise-variant angle: ROM#1 PURPLE FOIL MASK#1 Blind Bag Exclusive Surprise Variant Unread NM, with a blind bag, purple foil mask wording, unread NM phrasing, and Issue Number 1.
- Best for a Bat-family character mix: Robins #1 Babs Tarr Nightwing Dick Grayson Locker Room Workout Cover NM, with Damian Wayne, Red Hood, Stephanie Brown, and Tim Drake named in the attributes.
Listed price comparison
The price range runs from USD 4.74 to USD 124.00, so the lowest listed option is 96% below the highest. That spread matters: one pick is clearly positioned around CGC 9.8 and Supergirl key-issue attributes, while the others cluster at lower listed prices for variant-cover and unread-style collecting.
| Product | Listed price | Relative price bar |
|---|---|---|
| Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow #1 CGC 9.8 1st Print Bilquis Evely Cover Tom King | USD 124.00 | |
| Catwoman #89 Cover E Homare Swimsuit Card Stock Variant | USD 4.74 | |
| ROM#1 PURPLE FOIL MASK#1 Blind Bag Exclusive Surprise Variant Unread NM | USD 25.00 | |
| Robins #1 Babs Tarr Nightwing Dick Grayson Locker Room Workout Cover NM | USD 25.00 |
Decision matrix
| Shopper priority | Strongest fit | Why it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Slabbed Supergirl display or collection focus | Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow #1 CGC 9.8 1st Print Bilquis Evely Cover Tom King | The title names CGC 9.8, first print, Bilquis Evely cover, Tom King, and the attributes include Kara Zor-El, Supergirl. |
| Lowest entry price in this set | Catwoman #89 Cover E Homare Swimsuit Card Stock Variant | It is the lowest listed price and carries a Brand New condition note. |
| Blind-bag or surprise-variant collecting | ROM#1 PURPLE FOIL MASK#1 Blind Bag Exclusive Surprise Variant Unread NM | The title emphasizes blind bag, exclusive surprise variant, unread NM, and purple foil mask wording. |
| Multiple Robin-related characters | Robins #1 Babs Tarr Nightwing Dick Grayson Locker Room Workout Cover NM | The attributes name Damian Wayne, Red Hood, Stephanie Brown, and Tim Drake, while the title highlights Nightwing Dick Grayson. |
| Modern Age single-issue collecting | Supergirl, ROM, or Robins | Each is tied to Modern Age attributes, though their collecting angles differ sharply. |
| Variant-cover emphasis | Catwoman, ROM, or Robins | Catwoman names Cover E and card stock, ROM names a surprise variant, and Robins names a Babs Tarr cover. |
Concise product notes
Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow #1 CGC 9.8 1st Print Bilquis Evely Cover Tom King
This is the clearest pick for a shopper who wants the Supergirl angle to be the center of the purchase. The title combines CGC 9.8, 1st Print, Bilquis Evely cover, and Tom King, while the attributes add Kara Zor-El, Supergirl, First Printing, First Character Appearance, Key Issue, A Cover, Single Issue, and Superheroes. It also lists Certified Guaranty Company in the autograph authentication line. The tradeoff is simple: it is the highest listed price in the group by a large margin, and the condition field is marked unspecified rather than using a plain comic-condition phrase such as Brand New or Like New.
Catwoman #89 Cover E Homare Swimsuit Card Stock Variant
Catwoman #89 is the easiest choice if the goal is to add a DC Comics Catwoman variant at the lowest listed cost among these four. The title gives you the main collecting hook: Cover E, Homare, swimsuit, and card stock variant. The description also frames the issue around Selina, Alley Town, and Black Mask's plan, so it may appeal to shoppers who want Catwoman story context rather than only cover terminology. Its limitation is that the attributes are sparse compared with the other entries: beyond DC Comics, Brand New, and Item Weight: 60, it does not name artist/writer, era, format, issue number, or genre in the attribute list.
ROM#1 PURPLE FOIL MASK#1 Blind Bag Exclusive Surprise Variant Unread NM
ROM#1 stands out for collectors drawn to packaging and variant language. The title stacks several hooks: purple foil, mask, blind bag, exclusive surprise variant, unread, and NM. The attributes identify Robert Kirkman and Lorenzo De Felici, Ship, Brand New condition, United States country of origin, Modern Age era, Boarded, Single Issue, Issue Number 1, Publication Year 2026, and skybound as publisher. That gives it more structured comic information than the Catwoman entry. The main limitation is that the blind-bag and surprise-variant wording means the appeal is tied to that surprise format, which may be less direct than choosing a specific named cover image or character-led DC issue.
Robins #1 Babs Tarr Nightwing Dick Grayson Locker Room Workout Cover NM
Robins #1 is the strongest fit here for a shopper who wants a Robin-family or Bat-family character spread. The attributes name Damian Wayne, Red Hood (Jason Todd), Stephanie Brown, and Tim Drake, while the title adds Nightwing Dick Grayson and Babs Tarr cover wording. It also lists Like New condition, Modern Age era, 1st Edition, Collector's Edition, Variant Cover, Superheroes, Issue Number 1, and DC Comics. The limitation is that its certification attribute is Uncertified, so it does not offer the same slabbed CGC 9.8 presentation angle as the Supergirl pick. It is better viewed as a character-and-cover-focused collectible than a graded-display option.
How to choose between them
Start with the role you want the comic to play in your collection. If you want a single centerpiece around Kara Zor-El and a clearly labeled CGC 9.8 issue, the Supergirl title is the natural fit. It is also the only one here with First Printing, First Character Appearance, Key Issue, and A Cover grouped together in the attributes, which gives it a more defined key-issue profile than the other three.
If price is the deciding factor, Catwoman #89 is the clear outlier. Its listed price is far below the rest of the set, and the product name still gives a specific variant identity through Cover E, Homare, swimsuit, and card stock wording. The narrower attribute set makes it less detail-rich than ROM or Robins, but the Catwoman and DC Comics angle is straightforward.
For collectors who enjoy variant mechanics and unread-style wording, ROM#1 has the most distinctive format language. Blind Bag Exclusive Surprise Variant and PURPLE FOIL MASK#1 are the phrases doing the work here. It is also the only option in the group with Publication Year 2026 and skybound as publisher in the attributes, making it feel separate from the DC-heavy choices.
Robins #1 sits in the middle as a DC character pick with a broader ensemble. It does not lean on a graded label, but it does combine Nightwing Dick Grayson in the title with multiple Robin-linked characters in the attributes. That makes it useful for someone collecting around Damian Wayne, Jason Todd, Stephanie Brown, or Tim Drake rather than one solo lead.
Final recommendation
Choose Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow #1 CGC 9.8 1st Print Bilquis Evely Cover Tom King if you want the most defined graded Supergirl collectible in this group and are comfortable with the USD 124.00 listed price. The CGC 9.8 title wording, Kara Zor-El/Supergirl attributes, and First Printing/Key Issue details make it the strongest centerpiece-style choice.
Choose Catwoman #89 Cover E Homare Swimsuit Card Stock Variant if you want the lowest listed price at USD 4.74 and a clear Catwoman variant-cover identity. Choose ROM#1 PURPLE FOIL MASK#1 Blind Bag Exclusive Surprise Variant Unread NM if the blind-bag surprise and unread NM phrasing are the main draw. Choose Robins #1 Babs Tarr Nightwing Dick Grayson Locker Room Workout Cover NM if you want a DC Comics issue centered on Nightwing and multiple Robin-family characters at USD 25.00.